I’m going to talk about a concept called Radical Honesty and how it compares with business ethics.
“Ethics” vs. Honesty
Perhaps ironically, ethics and honesty do not go hand-in-hand. We had a short seminar on business ethics at my workplace which in general, concluded with the message “don’t offend people”.
Do people have a right to NOT be offended? Of course not. But “having the right” to offend someone does not mean that it’s right to offend them. It’s usually better to refrain from telling someone how you really feel about them than risk them getting upset…or is it? We can all agree that certain off-color jokes are inappropriate in the office, but what about withholding information about how you feel about someone.
Is withholding information deceitful? Aren’t you withholding your true feelings just so they’ll like you? That’s not honest. It’s manipulation. And it’s certainly not a part of Radical Honesty.
Radical Honesty
Radical Honesty is a lifestyle. In order to live this lifestyle, you must tell people how you feel about them…whenever your feelings about them change…and you must tell them about everything they’ve done to change your feelings.
Suppose there is a husband and wife who are radically honest. If his wife ask him if she looks fat in those pants and he thinks that she does, then he says, “Yes, you do look fat in those pants.”
This sounds like a bad idea, doesn’t it? She’d understandably be upset. Everyone gets upset and that’s okay, because as long as she is reciprocally honest with him, “I resent you for tell me I look fat”, then tension can go away quickly.
Maybe she didn’t really to know if she looked fat, but she was fishing for compliments.
Then she might say, “I resent you for not complimenting me.” Now they’re really communicating. He doesn’t tell her enough that he appreciates her. Now they can improve their relationship.
Radical Honesty means that you release all of the tension you carry around in your relationships by releasing your anger you have about that person, and you listen to their resentments about you. You’re no longer walking on eggshells around that person. How could you be when everything has been laid on the table. You can start real communication between two people.
You might think this is a bad idea that can ruin relationships. Yes, it might. But maybe those are relationships that aren’t worth the constant maintenance and withholding. If being honest means you no longer like each other, then it’s not a relationship worth keeping.
Radical Honesty + Business
This sounds fine and dandy for relationships with friends and family, but what about your relationship with your coworkers. You could lose your job if you were honest! But if you have to lie to your boss and coworkers, certainly there’s a better job out there for you. Hell, you might get a promotion for showing you have confidence in yourself.
All the time, we lie to people so that we don’t offend them. Not only that, but we lie to ourselves about what we think. And that’s the worst part, because it allows us to become prejudice or on the other hand, to keep us walking on eggshells for the entire length of a relationship, like with your in-laws. Comedienne Alicia Dattner found out that a little honest help her let go of some preconceptions about a show she was about to do.
If you’ve ever read anything about Neuro-Linguistic Programming (a self-therapy type of thinking…not really a science), one thing you’ll see is that everyone is doing the best they can for themselves in their current situation. This alone might be a radical concept for some people. But if you can consider that, then we must accept that there is a reason behind someone else’s behavior towards you. It’s a cop out to say, “He’s just a jerk and we’ll never get along.” Radical Honesty forces you to find out the motives for somebody’s behavior. It gives you a place to understand why they act the way they do and why you interpret it as rude behavior. Just remember, being honest with someone sometimes comes off as being rude
What does this have do with business ethics? Once you’re honest with people, they can trust you. There will be real communication. That’s good for productivity, at least according to The Bader Group.
Does it work with customers? I worked on commission as an electronics salesman at a large retail chain several years ago. I certainly wouldn’t consider myself radically honest, however I didn’t bullshit customers. I tried to help them save their money, “Well, this model does the same thing as this one, but it’s a lot cheaper. This is a reputable brand and if you buy the extended warranty, you’re still saving money and can get a new one if it breaks.” In the short run, I lost commission. If I had stuck around that job longer, I think I would have found that it would have worked out well for me in the long run by creating customer satisfaction. Repeat business means more money.
The key to Radical Honesty is that you let all your anger and tension out immediately. Anger that we would normally keep inside and pretend it’s not there. That anger creates tension in our relationships with people. If your mom said something to you that hurt your feelings, pretending that it didn’t bother you because you didn’t want to hurt her feelings will add a bit of tension to your relationship. And as you repeat this withholding of anger over time, your relationship suffers. You can’t connect on a deeper level because part of your doesn’t trust her. Plus, you’ve filtered the truth because you don’t think she can handle it. Letting her know that you’re angry when you get angry, offending her, and then getting over it together ensures that you’re not holding any tension. If you tell someone when they’re being a jerk right up front and stay with them while they get mad and talk about it, you’ll both get over it together. Even more radical than that, the author says you should discuss about all the things that person has done to anger you throughout your entire relationship. Once you’ve both talked about all the things you’ve been hiding from each other and explained your feelings, there will be no more tension. How could there be? You’re not hiding anything. You’re not going to be going around holding that anger, trying to hide it from them anymore. The result is you’re just two human beings having a real honesty conversation. Probably for the first time in your life.
How It’s Worked for Me
This “releasing” your anger thing is the opposite of what I started doing years ago. I realized I had a short temper and would take it out physically on walls, pillows, objects that could be thrown, etc… All alone, of course. I didn’t want people to know I got that angry. I realized how silly it was. I just made a resolve to stop letting things get to me. To a certain extent, I’ve been able to do this. I realize that most people have good intentions and petty things do not get to me. However, I still get annoyed at times and instead of releasing that anger, I find myself thinking about it and thinking of good come-backs. Pretty lame, right! Radical Honesty is the opposite of this. Don’t fool yourself into thinking you’ll tell everyone everything they’ve ever done to make me angry. But start being more honest when someone says does something you don’t like…and also when they do something that you do like.
The idea is freeing. If I don’t like you, I can honestly tell you where I think you should go. I don’t feel intimidated…after all, if I think you’re being overbearing, I’m won’t hide it. I’ll let you know that I resent your behavior.
Conclusion
This doesn’t quite mesh with creating a stable work environment. No, I do not recommend radical honesty if you’re afraid of losing your job. If you are a bigot or overly sexual, I wouldn’t recommend it because you will get fired. However, if you don’t think you’d get fired for being honest (you have an open-minded boss) or you don’t mind losing your job, then you’re situation will almost certainly improve because you’ll not only relieve that tension but you’ll might even get a raise if you come right out and say you deserve one. Or you boss or coworkers might stop doing things that are annoying or counterproductive. And if not, then ask yourself why you want to work there at all.
You might want to keep some things off topic. Religion and politics aren’t necessary to talk about. If you resent people who bring those topics up, let them know. Be nice about it! Being honest and having tact are two different things that can be done at the same time.